top of page
Fiction Manuscript Evaluation


A manuscript evaluation gives you detailed feedback on what works in your story and what doesn't. You'll receive a report full of tips and actionable feedback to improve your novel, and there'll be plenty of opportunities to discuss your project and the feedback with me too.

Manuscript evaluations are for:
  • New authors who want to query or self-publish confidently

  • More experienced authors who feel something isn't right or does not work in their novel

  • Authors who want to take their writing up a level and discuss their craft

  • Authors who want to better understand what they do well and what is unique about their style

My aim is to leave you feeling well-supported, aware of what you do well and what could be improved, and with a clear plan of what to do next.

The main thing you will receive is an editorial letter with a report on:


  • Problems with your manuscript

  • Things you do well

  • Audience

  • Point of view

  • Plot

  • Pacing

  • Characters

  • Character arcs

  • Setting/worldbuilding

  • Culture and representation

  • Messaging/subtexts

The report will also include a possible revision plan, links to relevant resources, and next steps.

I specialise in science fiction, fantasy, and horror. I also enjoy working on historical fiction, coming-of-age stories, LGBTQ+ literature, and literary fiction.


My background in cultural anthropology means I am the perfect choice for any fiction dealing with social themes or topics linked to cultural and representation.


If you have problems with setting or worldbuilding, I can give you detailed feedback on social, cultural, and political dimensions involved.

About Me

Hi there! I’m Dr Andrew Hodges, the owner of The Narrative Craft. With my kick-ass editorial expertise in setting and worldbuilding, I'll make sure your novel is the best it can be!

WhatsApp Image 2022-05-24 at 9.56.52 PM.jpeg

What services do I offer?

I offer two services: a basic evaluation, and a detailed evaluation. You can find more information about these services below.

Detailed evaluation
  • two close read throughs of your manuscript 

  • a detailed report of twelve to fifteen pages on the issues listed above

  • comments on your manuscript

  • a content summary

  • an hour of online coaching or support via Zoom.

Cost: $20 per 1000 words

Basic evaluation
  • one close read through of your manuscript

  • a report (editorial letter) of eight to ten pages on the issues listed above

  • an hour of online support and feedback via Zoom.

Cost: $10 per 1000 words

I knew the text was in safe, professional hands, but the depth of Andrew’s immersion in the text and his careful judgement impressed me. The final version is certainly better than I could have imagined!

Iva Babic, Fiction Author

Need some more info?

Why pick me?

My expertise in setting, worldbuilding and cultural issues mean I am a great fit for projects that have heavier real-world implications. Before choosing me, I recommend you check out:

Check out my testimonials above, too, for comments from authors I have worked with.

Why bother?

If you're self-publishing or seeking representation, then you want to avoid making any embarrassing errors, and get targeted feedback that will take your writing up a notch.

One way to do this is through a master's programme in creative writing. But these programmes are full-time commitments that often cost around £10K. 

Developmental editors can offer detailed feedback for a fraction of that price, as they don't have the same overheads that large universities have.

What if I don't like your vibe?

All manuscript evaluations begin with a short online consultation. If you don't think I'm the right fit for your project, I will offer you a full refund after the call, no questions asked.

How long will it take?

You should expect me to take one or two months to return your manuscript. This all depends on my schedule and how long your book is. I'll give you a firm deadline before starting work.

If you have any more questions, feel free to ask! Otherwise, you can book this service here:

press to zoom
press to zoom
press to zoom
press to zoom
bottom of page